The team recognizes student-athletes from each varsity sport who have demonstrated outstanding dedication to sportsmanship. The athletes were selected to the team by their teammates and coaches.

Senior baseball player Zak Starr (Westport, Conn.), softball player Alaina Clark (Casco, Maine), sophomore women's lacrosse player Carly Rapaport (Cape Elizabeth, Maine), senior men's lacrosse player Dana McNally (Sudbury, Mass.), senior men's rower Sam Fabens (Ithaca, N.Y.), senior women's rower Sasha Bartels (Hanover, N.H.), senior men's tennis player Zack Schuman (Watchung, N.J.), sophomore women's tennis player Audrey Jacobsen (San Juan Capistrano, Calif.), senior men's track and field athlete Camden Bucsko (Cumberland, Maine), and senior women's track and field athlete Anna King (Greenland, N.H.) were Colby's selections.