| Year | Name |
| 1965-1972 | Club Sport |
| 1973 | Sten Goodhope |
| 1974 | Sten Goodhope, Richard Steinberg |
| 1975 | Ned Battey, Joe Steinberg, Doug Windsor |
| 1976 | Joth Davis, Aubrey Moore, Peter Shaw |
| 1977 | Charlie Burch |
| 1978 | Alex Buck, Gilbert Pitcairn |
| 1979 | Gary McCarthy, Richardson White |
| 1980 | Jeffrey Dropo, R. Charles White |
| 1981 | Chris Bauer, Joel Castleman, Patrick Fortin |
| 1982 | Patrick Fortin, Marc Jaton, Richard Vocherot |
| 1983 | Michael Coval, Ray Kelley, Peter Ruggles |
| 1984 | John Lyons, Peter Newman |
| 1985 | Thomas Cushman, Henry 'Gus' Wilmerding |
| 1986 | Steve Gelto, Doug Parker, Henry 'Gus' Wilmerding |
| 1987 | William Clapp, Andrew Palmer |
| 1988 | Greg Cunningham, Joe Bisson |
| 1989 | Andrew Ayers, Kevin Plummer, Andrew Simmons |
| 1990 | Peter Ginolfi, Jason Mazzola, Eric Russman |
| 1991 | Peter Ginolfi, Jason Mazzola, Eric Russman |
| 1992 | Andy Benson, Bruce Fougere, Greg Mahoney |
| 1993 | William Bush, Andrew Colligan, David McKee |
| 1994 | William Bush, Andrew Colligan, Mike King |
| 1995 | Jeff Harris, Brent McLean, Franchot Tone, Andy Vernon |
| 1996 | Brian Emme, Brett Nardini |
| 1997 | Seth Blumenthal, Nick Maumenee, Clay Houchin |
| 1998 | Brian Frank, Clay Houchin, Matt King |
| 1999 | Mark Melander, Brad Selig, Matt Williams |
| 2000 | Jeremy Barron, Jeff Boyer, Ian Nurse |
| 2001 | Matt Cohen, Bill Getty |
| 2002 | Gabe Duncan-Roitman, John Shea, Bill Spencer |
| 2003 | Barron Butler, Ryan Tyler, Ben Winston |
| 2004 | Ryan Tyler |
| 2005 | Eric Seidel, Tom Deutsch |
| 2006 | Jeff Miller, Nate Werlin, Jonathan Bodansky |
| 2007 | Ryan Connolly, Kyle Haskett, Ryan Scott |
| 2008 | Dana McNally, Drew Piekarski |
